Introduction
One of the most misrepresented teachings in modern Christianity revolves around financial giving. Many preachers in the prosperity gospel movement use select Bible verses to claim that God promises financial blessings in return for monetary gifts. But what does the Bible actually teach about giving? Is there a biblical mandate to "sow financial seeds" for material gain, or is Christian giving about something far deeper?
In this post, we will explore the biblical foundation of giving, looking at both the Old and New Testament. We will distinguish between tithing and freewill offerings, examine Jesus' teachings on generosity, and establish what true biblical stewardship looks like.
We recognize that many believers have given out of sincere faith and love for God, genuinely trusting in His provision. This post is not about condemning those who have followed "seed sowing" teachings but about helping Christians discern biblical truth from manipulation.
Legal Battles Over Financial Seed Teaching
The prosperity gospel’s financial seed teachings have led to several lawsuits in North America, exposing fraudulent practices within some ministries:
Gospel for Asia (GFA) – In the U.S., GFA settled a $37 million lawsuit where plaintiffs accused them of misusing donations meant for charity. In Canada, a $100 million lawsuit was filed over similar allegations, with donors claiming their money was diverted to a multimillion-dollar personal empire instead of missions and poverty relief.
Robert Tilton’s Ministry – Investigations revealed that Tilton’s Success-N-Life program encouraged viewers to make financial vows with the promise of divine financial rewards, while donations primarily funded his luxurious lifestyle.
These legal cases underscore the danger of unchecked financial promises within ministries and the need for believers to demand transparency and accountability when giving.
A Personal Journey: Costi Hinn’s Escape from the Prosperity Gospel
Few people understand the inner workings of the prosperity gospel like Costi Hinn, nephew of world-renowned televangelist Benny Hinn. Growing up, Costi lived in unparalleled luxury—private jets, five-star hotels, designer clothes, and extravagant spending—all funded by ministry donations.
Yet behind the opulence, he felt a nagging dissonance. He saw desperate believers give sacrificially, convinced that their financial "seed" would yield miracles, while his family enjoyed lavish lifestyles without true sacrifice. Eventually, Costi’s convictions led him to question the theology he had been raised in.
Through careful Bible study and mentorship, he recognized that faith was never meant to be a business transaction with God. He ultimately left his uncle’s ministry, renounced prosperity theology, and committed himself to teaching biblical truth about giving. Today, he serves as a pastor and author, warning others about the dangers of financial manipulation in the church.
His story is a compelling reminder that true biblical giving is about faith, love, and stewardship—not wealth accumulation.
Old Testament Giving: Tithes and Offerings
Before we can understand biblical giving, we need to look at how it functioned in ancient Israel. The Old Testament primarily refers to giving in the form of tithes, offerings, and almsgiving.
1. The Tithe: A System of Provision, Not a Financial Investment
Leviticus 27:30-32 – The tithe was a required offering of 10% of a person's agricultural produce, given to support the Levites and priests.
Numbers 18:21-24 – The tithe was not an individual act of financial faith, but a provision for the priestly tribe of Levi.
Deuteronomy 14:22-29 – Some tithes were used for festivals and for supporting the poor, showing that giving had a communal focus.
Malachi 3:8-10 – A commonly misquoted verse; in context, it is a rebuke to Israel for failing to bring agricultural tithes, not a universal command to Christians.
The tithe was never a system where individuals gave money to receive more wealth. Instead, it was an act of obedience and communal support.
2. Freewill Offerings and Almsgiving
Exodus 25:1-2 – God instructed Moses to collect offerings from those who gave willingly.
Proverbs 19:17 – Giving to the poor was seen as honoring God.
Psalm 112:5 – Generosity was commended, but there was no promise of personal financial increase.
Even in the Old Testament, the focus of giving was communal care and worship, not financial prosperity.
New Testament Giving: A Shift to Heartfelt Generosity
Jesus and the apostles redefined giving, shifting the emphasis from required tithes to voluntary generosity and love for others.
1. Jesus’ Teachings on Giving
Matthew 6:1-4 – Giving should be done privately and humbly, not for personal recognition.
Mark 12:41-44 – The widow’s offering showed that God values sacrificial giving, not the amount given.
Luke 6:38 – Often misused by prosperity preachers, this verse speaks about generosity in all aspects of life, not financial sowing.
Matthew 19:21 – Jesus challenges the rich young ruler to give to the poor, showing that wealth is not a sign of divine favor.
2. The Early Church Model of Giving
Acts 2:44-45, Acts 4:32-35 – The early believers shared their possessions voluntarily, helping those in need.
2 Corinthians 9:6-7 – Giving should be cheerful and voluntary, not coerced.
1 Timothy 6:17-19 – Paul instructs the wealthy to be generous and ready to share, not to expect wealth in return.
The New Testament never commands tithing for Christians, nor does it promise material wealth in return for giving. Instead, it emphasizes willing generosity, care for the needy, and trust in God’s provision.
Conclusion: Biblical Giving vs. Financial Seed Sowing
The Bible teaches generosity, stewardship, and care for the needy, not a promise of wealth through giving. The prosperity gospel has twisted scripture to promote financial gain, but true biblical giving is about faith, love, and obedience.
Many people have been sincerely deceived by these teachings, often with good intentions. If you've struggled with financial disappointment after giving, know that God sees your heart and does not require financial sacrifices to bless you. He desires faithfulness, wisdom, and love for others.
In our next post, we will examine how prosperity preachers misuse scripture to deceive believers into financial manipulation.
For deeper biblical insights, check out the Berean Post YouTube channel, where we explore the context of the prophets and their prophecies!
Comments